murder in Babylon

série: Alexandre le Grand
éditeur: Virgin
auteur: Philipps Graham
classement: biblio501
année: 2004
format: cartonné avec jaquette
état: TBE/N
valeur: 10 €
critère: ***
remarques: English book


1/ the final banquet
2/ forensic opinion

- Alexandre was now 32 years old and has
conquered nearly the whole world
after 32'000 km and 12 years of conquest,

>> p. 1 he was known as Alexander the Great,
however Alexander may have been the
undisputed master of much of the known world,
he was a slave to destiny, he did not die a
warrior's death in battle, but expired
as helpless as a baby in his own bed

- and according to Hieronymus of Cardia,
Alexander was murdered by poison
>> p. 2 description of the world
at the time of Alexander

- the accounts of Chares of Mytilene,
chamberlain and biographer of Alexander
as well as Aristobulus, military engineer
are considered as being the most trustworthy

>> p. 14 the death of Alexander by malaria
and/or typhoid was rejected by a team of
the university of Maryland,
the belief of the author is that Alexander
has been murdered by poisoning
done through a conspiracy within
the circle of close relatives
and in this book, he brings forward his
allegations and possible evidence
in that connection

>> p. 21 in fact, Alexander's body failed
to show any signs of decay for six days,
this bizarre preservation probably due to
the poison absorbed and the author was told
by the Poison Center of Los Angeles
that this corpse's state was mainly
due to poison

- the poison was most probably made of
vegetable toxins
such as aconite, hemlock and
belladona (nightshade)


3/ motive and opportunity

- the first suspicion was that Hephaestion
was also murdered by poison
- during the final banquet, it seems
that Alexander's madness
had made him throw caution to the wind

n.b. to act boldly by taking a risk without
worrying about the potential negative
consequences

>> p. 44 the list of suspects, eight in all:
- his three consorts (Barsine, Roxanne and Statira)
- his three senior officers ((Meleager,
Perdiccas and Seleucos)
- his brother Arridaeus and the butler
Iollas, son of Antipater


4/ Antipater - prelude to conquest

- he was appointed by Philip II,
commander of the Macedonian army
and trained with Theban military tactics,
namely creating the phalanx,
- the improvement of cavalry and the creation
of artillery as well as a kind of
military police force:
the heavy shield bearers called hypaspistes
>> p. 51 this was the blueprint for the army
that Alexander would later use to conquer
much of the known world

- moreover Philipp was a good diplomat
and arrange alliances by marrying many
princesses of neighbouring states


5/ Arridaeus, the early days

- he was Alexander's half-brother
from a previous marriage of Philip
- he was deficient in intellect owing to
bodily disease,
this, however, did not come upon him
in the course of nature of its own accord,
it is said that as a boy he displayed an
exceedingly gifted and noble disposition,
but after Olympias gave him drugs which
injured his body and ruined his mind

- Alexander however must have been fond
of his half-brother as he did not have him
killed as he did other potential claimants
- did Arridaeus harbour a bitter resentment
against Alexander for depriving him of
the throne and being humiliated ?
- in any case he arrived at Babylone
a few weeks before Alexander fell ill and
died, therefore he is one of the suspects


6/ Barsine, the glory years

- Barsine fell in love with Alexander but
was set aside when Alexander married Roxanne
although Barsine had given much help to
Alexander since the battle of Issus

- Barsine's father Artabazus was Alexander's
masterspy at the court of Darius
and Barsine's brother, Pharnabazus, chief of
the Persian navy after the death of Memnon,
was captured, then escaped so that he could
be safely returned to the Persian side,
thanks Barsine, he was not put to death
and became Alexander's ally after the battle
of Gaugameles

- Barsine was Alexander's lover for six years
and bore him his first child,
by june 323 BC, she was however a neglected woman
with every reason to despise Alexander
for jilting her for a girl less than half her age


7/ Seleucos, the harsh campaign

- in Bactria, Alexander was faced with a
protracted guerilla war,
Darius had no longer any son to succeed him
(his wife and young son were dead)
and therefore, Bessus, as satrap of Bactria,
was the most important man in Persia after
Darius who had been weakened in losing
two battles and had fled twice as a coward,
thus by eliminating Darius, Bessus became
king at his place rather easily

>> p. 105 description of the hypaspistes
whose commander-in-chief was Seleucos,
it was a kind of SS-Waffen, an elite troop,
an army within the army and Seleucos has
great influence in the army

>> p. 108 the affair with Philotas and
Nicanor (sons of Parmenion)
in which Seleucos was a whistleblower
(dénonciateur)
>> p. 111 the convict death battalion
>> p. 117 with his hypaspistes reputation of brutality,
Alexander was now considered rather like a
butcher than a conqueror
>> p. 118 the affair with the death of Clitus
- due to his strong position, Seleucos may
well have eyes on Alexander's crown


8/ Roxanne meaning "little star",
land of mystery

>> p. 132 the campaign into Magadha (atfer
the one against Porus)
was to prove a disaster that almost cost
Alexander his crown
- Roxanne was humiliated when Alexander
married Statira, Darius' daughter
(a marriage made mostly for political reasons)
she was therefore one of a pirincipal for
poisoning Alexander
but could such an endearing and seemingly
spiritually minded woman
really have killed her husband three years
later because he had taken a second queen?
(it was said that Roxanne already had
poisoned Hephaestion)


9/ Meleager, the long march home

- he was commander of the Macedonian infantry
and had spectacular military achievements,
but he was no longer in line with Alexander
- Meleager survived the purge but he must
have felt his position,
even his life, to under threat and it seems
that Meleager had every reason
in the world to wish Alexander dead


10/ Statira, a sentence to death

- after the death of his mother and
her young brother as well as her father
and following the destruction of Persepolis,
Statira did not love Alexander, when he
married her and it was said that she promised
to assassinate Alexander


11/ Perdiccas, the last days

>> p. 168 the word magician coming from the
sect of the Zoroastrian Magi

- at the death of Hephaestion,
Perdiccas became deputy of Alexander,
but this was probably a temporary appointment
and Perdiccas would soon be replaced,
if Perdiccas was aware of this,
then it certainly gave him a motive for
killing Alexander


12/ an empire divided

- at Alexander's death and after much
discussion, Perdiccas allied with Seleucos
as his deputy, took the regency,
but his position remained precarious
- Antipater remained governor in Europe,
Ptolemy received Egypt,
Nearchos became governor of western
Asia Minor (Ionia),
a general named Antigonus was governor
of the east region (Cappodecia and Armenia?)
whereas Seleucos within the next three years
had taken control of the entire eastern
empire and founded the Seleucid Empire
which was to get the greatest part of
Alexander's empire


13/ symbols of succession

- Meleager and Statira were the only
two suspects on the list to have
already been in Babylon when Alexander
arrived May 323 BC
- however Meleager was captured
and executed by Perdiccas and Meleager
would not have been the murderer
as he would have prepared his coup
much better in advance

>> p. 194 as a child, Statira had sworn that
she would one day kill Alexander
and she had approved the Zoroastrian death
sentence by the priests
but doing this murder she would have now to
restore Persian power and this was not
possible as she did not make alliance with
any Persian allies so far
such for exemple Atarepata, the only Persian
ruler on his own at that time
(he created the independent province
Atropatema, later on Azerbadjan)
- in fact Statira was quite on her own and
soon after the death of Alexander,
she was executed by Roxanne with the
permission of Perdiccas

>> p. 197 the transport of Alexander's
body to Macedonia which was intercepted by
Ptolemy and as Antipater was also planning to
get the body, the mystery remains about
what really happened to Alexander's corpse
>> p. 199 it is ironic that the most famous
soldier who ever lived
should have had such an undignified epitaph
- and after the death of Perdiccas, the
empire was divided into three sections:
a) Ptolemy got Egypt as well as Gaza,
Judah and Palestine
b) Macedonia and Greece remained
under the command of Antipater
c) the largest part of Alexander's empire was
kept by Seleucos incl. the Indian part

- Asia Minor was the only region not fully
under anyone's control
and was fought over by the Asians and
Europeans for many years


14/ the Aegean dream

>> p. 203 description of the Aegean sea and
its population hereof the Minoan civilization
on the island of Creta

- Barsine and Nearchus intended to create a
new kingdom with the Aegean islands
and the Ionian cities which would have been
called Anatolia but they did not succeed
in performing their dream
as Barsine and her son were captured
by Cassandra and executed
during an absence of Nearchus who finished
his life being retired on Creta
- those two could therefore probably not be
involved in the murder of Alexander

15/ a warrior queen (Olympias)

could Olympias be involved in the plot
against her own son?
she had already manipulated Pausanias in the
murder of Philipp II
and had some resentment towards Alexander,
so she could have manipulated Arridaeus with
the murder of Alexander
and she was also expert with drugs and
poisonous plants
- if Olympias did manipulate Arridaeus to
poison Alexander then her attempts to accuse
others of this murder would have been part of
her plan, but Olympias' action towards her
own son would have been difficult to prove


16/ establishing means (Perdiccas)

- he was above all an intrigant and therefore
a main suspect
>> p. 229 description of Hephaestion's death,
similar to the one of Alexander
- as the best suited plant for poisoning
Alexander was the strychnine plant
found in India, rather rare as specific
to only some regions and unknown to doctors
of that period except for the Indian sage Kalyana
- as Perdiccas was unaware of this special
poison, we can deduct that he was not the
murder


17/ the murder unveiled (Roxanne)

- in fact, Roxanne is the most likely suspect
in murdering Alexander,
she planned her action to the perfection,
and she was the only one who had knowledge of
the strychnine poison
probably through the unvoluntary intermediary
of Kalyana,
he tried to dissuade Roxanne,
but was then also eliminated
when arriving in Babylon (self-immolation)
n.b. he tried to warn Alexander with his prophecy

- as a princess of proud Sogdian character,
Roxanne's likely motive had been jealousy of
Alexander's mariage with Statira,
she was also kept aside by Hephaestion whom
was probably also murdered by Roxanne
and having the support of Perdiccas for her
child to come to be recognised
as heir of Alexander,
she also had shortly after Alexander's death
Statira and Drypetis executed
- unfortunately Roxanne and her son
Alexander IV were not to reign
and were on their turn executed by Cassander

Conclusion
Roxanne is the most likely person who could
have murdered Alexander
>> p. 245 the scenario of Roxanne's plan

>> however the author is not completely
certain about Alexander's murder,
however his story is worth being considered
and is written like an investigaton by
Sherlock Holmes

annexes
- book cover
- three paintings of Alexander's
death from various origins


Information
Hieronymus of Cardia, Greek general and
historian from Cardia in Thrace,
was a contemporary of Alexander the Great,
after the death of Alexander he followed the
fortunes of his friend and fellow-countryman Eumenes,
he was wounded and taken prisoner by
Antigonus who pardoned him and appointed
him superintendent of the asphalt beds
in the Dead Sea,
he was treated with equal friendliness by
Antigonus's son Demetrius
who made him polemarch of Thespiae and by
Antigonus Gonatas,
at whose court he died at the age of 104 ?
he wrote a history of the Diadochi
and their descendants, embracing the period
from the death of Alexander to the war with
Pyrrhus (323–272 BC),
which is one of the chief authorities used by
Diodorus Siculus and also by Plutarch,

he made use of official papers and was
careful in his investigation of facts,
the simplicity of his style seemingly
rendered his work unpopular to people of his
time, but modern historians believe
it was very good in the last part of his work
he made a praiseworthy attempt
to acquaint the Greeks with the character and
early history of the romans,
he is reproached by Pausanias with unfairness
towards all rulers
with the exception of Antigonus Gonatas,
like the even more famous lost history of
Alexander by Ptolemy I of Egypt,
no significant amount of his work survived
the end of the ancient world

Chares of Mytilene was a Greek belonging to
the court of Alexander the Great,
he was appointed court-marshal or introducer
of strangers to the king,
an office borrowed from the Persian court,
he wrote a history of Alexander in ten books,
dealing mainly with the private life of the king,
the fragments are chiefly preserved in Athenaeus,
these fragments are largely concerned with
court ceremonies and personal gossip,
including a description of Alexander's
introduction of the Persian custom
of proskynesis to his court
(see Scriptores Rerum Alexandri (pp. 114–120)
in the Didot edition of Arrian

Aristobulus of Cassandreia, Greek historian,
son of Aristobulus,
probably a Phocian settled in Cassandreia,
he accompanied Alexander the Great
on his campaigns,
he served throughout as an architect and
military engineer
as well as a close friend of Alexander,
enjoying royal confidence,
and was entrusted with the repair of the tomb
of Cyrus the Great in Pasargadae,
he wrote an account, mainly geographical and
ethnological,
it survives only in quotations by others,
which may not all be faithful to the original,
his work was largely used by Arrian,
Plutarch also used him as a reference


couvertures:
Copyright 2008 - 2026 G. Rudolf